.jpg)
When neighborhood bookstores remembered your name or cafés asked if you wanted “the usual,” they weren’t building loyalty programs—they were building community. That human connection, long overshadowed by coupon codes and points, is now making a serious comeback. As retail moves beyond transaction-based loyalty, brands are starting to rebuild something that once came naturally: trust through belonging.
Retail has always been about people, but somewhere along the way, automation and short-term incentives became the dominant tools. Discounts flooded inboxes. Punch cards became apps. And customer data, once a source of connection, turned into just another KPI. This worked for a time, especially in a world driven by volume. But retention metrics are now stalling, acquisition costs are rising, and consumers are tuning out. The problem isn’t that loyalty programs are broken. It’s that many forgot what loyalty actually means.
In today’s retail space, customers expect more than rewards—they want to feel involved. A sense of belonging has replaced convenience as the top differentiator for younger audiences. Gen Z and younger millennials are less interested in traditional loyalty schemes and more drawn to brands that invite participation, amplify their values, and give them a voice.
Look at the rise of community-driven brands like Gymshark or Glossier. Neither launched with points programs. Instead, they focused on user-generated content, ambassador programs, and direct communication with customers. Their communities didn't just follow; they built alongside them. That sort of interaction isn’t measured in dollars spent—it’s measured in memes shared, events attended, and feedback implemented.
And it’s not just DTC brands. Retailers like REI and Sephora have leaned into community-based engagement. REI’s co-op model literally gives customers a stake in the brand, while Sephora’s Beauty Insider Community acts as a forum where people trade tips, post tutorials, and celebrate wins. Both companies have found that when customers invest emotionally, they stay longer and spend more.
There’s a reason customer acquisition has become so expensive—it’s not just digital ad inflation. People don’t trust ads the way they used to. But they trust each other. A referral from a friend is more effective than any paid campaign. That trust doesn’t come from loyalty tiers; it comes from shared experience.
Brand communities don’t form overnight. They take nurturing, transparency, and consistency. But once formed, they become powerful feedback loops. Members help shape product decisions. They defend your reputation in public forums. They create content, host events, and advocate without being asked. In many cases, your best customers become your best marketers—and not because you gave them points, but because you gave them purpose.
Nike’s shift with its Nike Run Club and Training Club apps is a good study. The apps are built around user communities, where achievements are celebrated, milestones tracked, and encouragement flows freely. These users aren’t just wearing the brand—they’re living in it.
Too many loyalty programs still operate on a transactional model: buy more, get more. But when everything is gamified, people begin to game the system. Loyalty becomes price-driven, not relationship-driven.
.jpg)
This is where retail must rethink the metrics that matter. Instead of focusing on repeat purchase rates alone, brands should track participation. Who shows up? Who contributes ideas? Who brings friends into the fold? The community-led model focuses less on the lifetime value of a single shopper and more on the network effect of connected fans.
And this is where platforms like Rediem offer a smarter approach. By tying loyalty actions to real-world behaviors—like joining brand-led initiatives, participating in challenges, or supporting shared causes—Rediem enables companies to reward actions that reflect true engagement, not just transactions. It's a shift from “how much did they spend?” to “how much did they care?”
Retailers often think in terms of audiences—something to be targeted, measured, and segmented. But communities are different. They aren’t built top-down. They emerge when brands create the conditions for connection.
That means giving customers more than just content. Give them roles. Let them shape product drops, vote on creative directions, or test unreleased items. Create private groups or forums where your most engaged supporters can interact directly with your team. These don’t have to be large initiatives. Sometimes the most successful community engagement are the simplest: a note in a package, a spotlight on a customer, a reply in a forum.
Also, don’t underestimate the power of shared values. Brands that champion sustainability, inclusion, or social causes shouldn’t just post about it—they should build community efforts around them. Patagonia’s Action Works or Ben & Jerry’s Justice campaigns are examples of community as alignment. People stick with brands that show up with them, not just sell to them.
One of the biggest mistakes companies make when trying to “build community” is treating it as a marketing campaign. Community is a long game. It requires cross-functional support—from CX to product, from support to leadership. If your service team isn’t empowered to act like community stewards, or if your product roadmap doesn’t reflect user input, customers will notice.
This also means shifting how success is measured. Not every community activity will have immediate ROI. Some will. But others—like customer-led meetups or online events—build equity over time. The point isn’t to force virality. It’s to create spaces where trust can grow.
When people feel a sense of ownership, they behave differently. They give feedback not as critics, but as co-creators. They celebrate wins. They forgive small stumbles. They don’t switch brands over a 10% discount from a competitor. This isn’t just loyalty—it’s advocacy.
The retail brands that succeed over the next five years will be those that build platforms for connection, not just commerce. Loyalty won’t be won through better discounts, but through better relationships. And community is the infrastructure for those relationships.
The brands that recognize this now will be the ones customers remember—not because they gave rewards, but because they made them feel part of something worth being loyal to.
When neighborhood bookstores remembered your name or cafés asked if you wanted “the usual,” they weren’t building loyalty programs—they were building community. That human connection, long overshadowed by coupon codes and points, is now making a serious comeback. As retail moves beyond transaction-based loyalty, brands are starting to rebuild something that once came naturally: trust through belonging.
Retail has always been about people, but somewhere along the way, automation and short-term incentives became the dominant tools. Discounts flooded inboxes. Punch cards became apps. And customer data, once a source of connection, turned into just another KPI. This worked for a time, especially in a world driven by volume. But retention metrics are now stalling, acquisition costs are rising, and consumers are tuning out. The problem isn’t that loyalty programs are broken. It’s that many forgot what loyalty actually means.
In today’s retail space, customers expect more than rewards—they want to feel involved. A sense of belonging has replaced convenience as the top differentiator for younger audiences. Gen Z and younger millennials are less interested in traditional loyalty schemes and more drawn to brands that invite participation, amplify their values, and give them a voice.
Look at the rise of community-driven brands like Gymshark or Glossier. Neither launched with points programs. Instead, they focused on user-generated content, ambassador programs, and direct communication with customers. Their communities didn't just follow; they built alongside them. That sort of interaction isn’t measured in dollars spent—it’s measured in memes shared, events attended, and feedback implemented.
And it’s not just DTC brands. Retailers like REI and Sephora have leaned into community-based engagement. REI’s co-op model literally gives customers a stake in the brand, while Sephora’s Beauty Insider Community acts as a forum where people trade tips, post tutorials, and celebrate wins. Both companies have found that when customers invest emotionally, they stay longer and spend more.
There’s a reason customer acquisition has become so expensive—it’s not just digital ad inflation. People don’t trust ads the way they used to. But they trust each other. A referral from a friend is more effective than any paid campaign. That trust doesn’t come from loyalty tiers; it comes from shared experience.
Brand communities don’t form overnight. They take nurturing, transparency, and consistency. But once formed, they become powerful feedback loops. Members help shape product decisions. They defend your reputation in public forums. They create content, host events, and advocate without being asked. In many cases, your best customers become your best marketers—and not because you gave them points, but because you gave them purpose.
Nike’s shift with its Nike Run Club and Training Club apps is a good study. The apps are built around user communities, where achievements are celebrated, milestones tracked, and encouragement flows freely. These users aren’t just wearing the brand—they’re living in it.
Too many loyalty programs still operate on a transactional model: buy more, get more. But when everything is gamified, people begin to game the system. Loyalty becomes price-driven, not relationship-driven.
This is where retail must rethink the metrics that matter. Instead of focusing on repeat purchase rates alone, brands should track participation. Who shows up? Who contributes ideas? Who brings friends into the fold? The community-led model focuses less on the lifetime value of a single shopper and more on the network effect of connected fans.
And this is where platforms like Rediem offer a smarter approach. By tying loyalty actions to real-world behaviors—like joining brand-led initiatives, participating in challenges, or supporting shared causes—Rediem enables companies to reward actions that reflect true engagement, not just transactions. It's a shift from “how much did they spend?” to “how much did they care?”
Retailers often think in terms of audiences—something to be targeted, measured, and segmented. But communities are different. They aren’t built top-down. They emerge when brands create the conditions for connection.
That means giving customers more than just content. Give them roles. Let them shape product drops, vote on creative directions, or test unreleased items. Create private groups or forums where your most engaged supporters can interact directly with your team. These don’t have to be large initiatives. Sometimes the most successful community engagement are the simplest: a note in a package, a spotlight on a customer, a reply in a forum.
Also, don’t underestimate the power of shared values. Brands that champion sustainability, inclusion, or social causes shouldn’t just post about it—they should build community efforts around them. Patagonia’s Action Works or Ben & Jerry’s Justice campaigns are examples of community as alignment. People stick with brands that show up with them, not just sell to them.
One of the biggest mistakes companies make when trying to “build community” is treating it as a marketing campaign. Community is a long game. It requires cross-functional support—from CX to product, from support to leadership. If your service team isn’t empowered to act like community stewards, or if your product roadmap doesn’t reflect user input, customers will notice.
This also means shifting how success is measured. Not every community activity will have immediate ROI. Some will. But others—like customer-led meetups or online events—build equity over time. The point isn’t to force virality. It’s to create spaces where trust can grow.
When people feel a sense of ownership, they behave differently. They give feedback not as critics, but as co-creators. They celebrate wins. They forgive small stumbles. They don’t switch brands over a 10% discount from a competitor. This isn’t just loyalty—it’s advocacy.
The retail brands that succeed over the next five years will be those that build platforms for connection, not just commerce. Loyalty won’t be won through better discounts, but through better relationships. And community is the infrastructure for those relationships.
The brands that recognize this now will be the ones customers remember—not because they gave rewards, but because they made them feel part of something worth being loyal to.
ready to make the switch? we automatically migrate your customers points from Yotpo, Smile and others so your customers don't miss a beat.
.png){kind=icon}
