Building a strong base of returning customers is crucial for long-term business success. While acquiring new customers is essential, nurturing existing ones can significantly boost profitability. In fact, studies show that returning customers tend to spend more and convert at higher rates than first-time buyers.

To effectively increase your returning customer rate, you need strategic loyalty initiatives that go beyond simple rewards programs. This article will explore proven strategies for increasing your returning customer rate and fostering lasting brand loyalty.

Understanding Returning Customer Rate

The returning customer rate (RCR) measures the percentage of customers who make two or more purchases within a set period. This metric reflects customer retention and brand loyalty, providing valuable insights into customer satisfaction and the effectiveness of your engagement efforts.

How to Calculate Returning Customer Rate

The formula for calculating RCR is:

Returning Customer Rate=(Returning CustomersTotal Customers)×100\text{Returning Customer Rate} = \left(\frac{\text{Returning Customers}}{\text{Total Customers}}\right) \times 100 Returning Customer Rate=(Total CustomersReturning Customers​)×100

For example, if you had 1,000 customers last month and 250 of them made a repeat purchase, your returning customer rate would be:

(250/1000)×100=25%(250 / 1000) \times 100 = 25\%(250/1000)×100=25%

What Is a Good Returning Customer Rate?

A healthy returning customer rate varies by industry. For most eCommerce businesses, the benchmark is around 20–30%.

• Above 50% – Indicates strong brand loyalty but may suggest a lack of new customer acquisition.
• Below 25% – Could imply issues with customer experience, product value, or post-purchase engagement.

If your rate is on the lower end, it's time to implement smart loyalty strategies to encourage repeat purchases.

Strategies to Increase Your Returning Customer Rate

Create a Meaningful Customer Loyalty Program

Traditional points-based programs often fail to keep customers engaged. Instead of focusing solely on discounts, modern loyalty programs should:

• Reward more than just purchases – Incentivize behaviors like social media engagement, reviews, referrals, and sustainable actions.
• Personalize rewards – Offer rewards based on customer preferences and shopping habits.
• Integrate with daily life – Provide perks that align with customers' interests, such as exclusive content, community access, or early product releases.

Example: A beauty brand could reward customers with points for recycling empty product containers, reinforcing both loyalty and sustainability.

Engage Customers Through Community Building

Customers are more likely to return if they feel connected to your brand beyond transactions. Creating a brand community can help:

• Foster discussions around shared interests.
• Provide exclusive content and experiences.
• Encourage user-generated content and brand advocacy.

Example: A fashion brand could create a private Facebook or Discord group where loyal customers get styling tips, early access to sales, and the opportunity to connect with like-minded shoppers.

Optimize Post-Purchase Engagement

Loyalty doesn’t end after checkout. A seamless post-purchase experience encourages repeat business. Strategies include:

• Personalized follow-up emails – Send thank-you messages, product care tips, and recommendations for complementary products.
• Proactive customer support – Offer easy returns, hassle-free exchanges, and responsive assistance.
• Order tracking transparency – Keep customers informed about their deliveries in real time.

Example: A home decor brand could follow up a furniture purchase with an email containing setup guides and styling suggestions.

Leverage Smart Referral Programs

Referrals don’t just bring in new customers—they also incentivize existing ones to stay engaged. A strong referral program should:

• Offer benefits for both the referrer and the new customer.
• Make sharing effortless through personalized links or social media integration.
• Align rewards with your brand’s value, such as discounts, exclusive products, or VIP status.

Example: A subscription box service could offer a free box for every three friends referred, creating a cycle of engagement.

Use Personalized Marketing to Keep Customers Engaged

Customers return when they feel valued and understood. Personalization is key to increasing engagement and retention:

• Segment customers based on purchase behavior and preferences.
• Send targeted recommendations based on past purchases.
• Use dynamic content in emails and on-site messaging to create a tailored shopping experience.

Example: A pet supply store could send pet owners reminders for when they might need to restock on food, based on their last purchase date.

Incentivize Repeat Purchases With Time-Sensitive Offers

Creating urgency can encourage customers to return sooner. Consider:

• Limited-time discounts for returning shoppers.
• Bonus points for purchases within a set timeframe.
• Seasonal or holiday-based promotions.

Example: An online grocery store could offer an exclusive 10% discount to customers who reorder within two weeks of their last purchase.

Improve the Overall Customer Experience

Ultimately, a seamless and enjoyable shopping experience is what keeps customers coming back. Focus on:

• Fast and reliable shipping – Offer free or expedited shipping for loyal customers.
• Mobile-friendly shopping – Ensure your site and loyalty programs are accessible via mobile apps.
• Hassle-free returns – A flexible return policy builds trust and encourages repeat purchases.

Example: A fashion retailer could offer free returns for loyalty members, making it risk-free to shop again.

The Role of Rediem in Increasing Customer Loyalty

Rediem takes loyalty to the next level by focusing on community engagement, social impact, and experiential rewards rather than just transactional points. With Rediem, brands can:

• Encourage sustainable and value-driven actions that align with their mission.
• Build meaningful customer relationships through community initiatives.
• Seamlessly integrate with other business apps to enhance loyalty programs.

By leveraging Rediem’s innovative platform, brands can shift from a transactional approach to a relationship-based loyalty model, leading to higher retention and increased customer lifetime value.

A high returning customer rate is a sign of strong brand loyalty and a healthy business. By implementing smart loyalty strategies such as meaningful rewards, community building, personalized marketing, and exceptional post-purchase engagement, you can turn one-time buyers into long-term advocates.

Modern brands must go beyond traditional loyalty programs and create a deeper emotional connection with customers. With tools like Rediem, businesses can foster a community-driven approach to loyalty, ensuring sustainable growth and customer retention.

Start focusing on engagement over transactions, and watch your returning customer rate—and revenue—soar.

‍