In an era where consumers can order nearly anything within hours and compare prices in seconds, brand loyalty is no longer secured by convenience or discounts alone. People want to align with companies that reflect their personal beliefs—whether those are about sustainability, inclusivity, or fairness in supply chains. Loyalty is being driven less by “What can I get?” and more by “Who do I become when I choose this brand?”
Businesses that recognize this shift are rethinking how they measure and cultivate loyalty. It’s no longer enough to keep customers coming back; the true goal is to create a bond strong enough that customers advocate for the brand because of what it represents.
Traditional loyalty programs were built on transactions: points per purchase, discounts after repeat visits, early access to sales. These models still work, but they don’t generate lasting emotional bonds. If another company offers a better discount, the customer can switch instantly.
Today’s consumers, especially younger generations, expect brands to align with their social, environmental, and cultural values. A McKinsey study revealed that 70% of Gen Z consumers try to purchase from brands they consider ethical, and 63% are willing to pay more to do so. This behavior points to a deeper kind of loyalty—where customers stay because leaving feels like betraying their own values.
Think about Patagonia’s consistent stance on environmental responsibility. When they ran their famous “Don’t Buy This Jacket” campaign, discouraging unnecessary consumption, it didn’t hurt sales—it strengthened loyalty. Customers didn’t just like Patagonia gear; they believed in Patagonia as a company. That level of trust can’t be won with coupons or tiered points alone.
Many brands attempt to attach themselves to cultural movements or causes, but consumers are increasingly skilled at spotting performative gestures. A recycled logo during Pride Month or a generic sustainability claim without proof doesn’t foster loyalty; it creates skepticism.
Authenticity requires consistent actions across the business. Starbucks faced criticism when promoting racial equity initiatives while simultaneously receiving backlash for internal policies that contradicted the message. The misalignment diluted trust. On the other hand, Ben & Jerry’s has repeatedly taken bold stances on social justice issues, often at risk of alienating some customer groups, but that very risk-taking has strengthened their loyal base who values courage and consistency.
The key takeaway: customers don’t need brands to stand for every cause, but they need them to stand firmly for the causes they do embrace—and show evidence of living those commitments across the business, not just in marketing campaigns.
Consider how Apple frames privacy as a core value in its marketing. Competitors may offer more affordable devices with comparable features, but Apple customers often choose to pay a premium because they believe their personal data is safer. That belief drives loyalty beyond features and price.
In food and beverage, brands like Oatly gained momentum not only because of product innovation but because they tapped into cultural conversations around climate change and animal welfare. Customers weren’t just buying oat milk; they were buying into a statement about the kind of future they wanted to see.
These examples highlight a growing truth: loyalty programs that focus only on transactions risk being commoditized. But when customers connect their purchase with a sense of identity or contribution to a greater purpose, they don’t simply consume—they participate.
Shared values naturally foster community, and community deepens loyalty. Nike’s investment in initiatives like “Nike Run Club” and “Nike Training Club” apps isn’t just about selling sneakers—it’s about uniting people around a shared commitment to health, performance, and self-improvement.
Community-driven loyalty often includes peer validation. Customers feel part of something bigger when they see others engaging in the same behaviors, whether that’s sharing workouts, posting eco-friendly purchases, or supporting small local makers. This network effect transforms loyalty into a collective experience, not an isolated transaction.
Platforms like Rediem support this by allowing brands to design communities that go beyond discounts. They enable customers to participate in shared missions, earn recognition for value-driven behaviors, and interact with each other in meaningful ways. When loyalty is framed as belonging rather than buying, it becomes far harder to break.
If loyalty is tied to values, businesses need to measure more than purchase frequency. Engagement indicators—such as participation in community programs, shares of cause-related content, or referrals driven by belief in the brand’s mission—become critical signals.
Brands like TOMS shifted their one-for-one giving model after realizing that while the campaign was popular, customers wanted deeper engagement with the causes they supported. Instead of only tracking how many pairs of shoes were donated, TOMS began focusing on long-term impact and storytelling around community projects. The metric of success became customer alignment and advocacy, not just units sold.
This shift in measurement allows marketers to evaluate not just who is buying, but why they are buying—and whether that “why” ties back to brand values in a way that ensures loyalty over time.
Taking a stand on values isn’t risk-free. By aligning strongly with certain beliefs, brands may alienate parts of their potential audience. Gillette’s 2019 campaign addressing toxic masculinity sparked widespread debate—garnering praise from some and boycotts from others.
The reality is that strong values create polarity. But neutrality can be even riskier. In a marketplace saturated with choices, blandness fails to inspire loyalty. Brands that choose to stand for something must prepare for backlash, but they also gain the chance to build a passionate, committed base that won’t switch for discounts.
Value-based loyalty is not a marketing tactic—it’s a brand identity strategy. Customers are no longer satisfied with transactional perks alone; they want to align their spending power with their beliefs. Brands that respond with authenticity, consistency, and measurable action will find themselves rewarded with something far stronger than repeat purchases: unwavering loyalty.
In the end, when customers choose you for what you stand for, they’re not just buying your product—they’re endorsing your place in their world.
In an era where consumers can order nearly anything within hours and compare prices in seconds, brand loyalty is no longer secured by convenience or discounts alone. People want to align with companies that reflect their personal beliefs—whether those are about sustainability, inclusivity, or fairness in supply chains. Loyalty is being driven less by “What can I get?” and more by “Who do I become when I choose this brand?”
Businesses that recognize this shift are rethinking how they measure and cultivate loyalty. It’s no longer enough to keep customers coming back; the true goal is to create a bond strong enough that customers advocate for the brand because of what it represents.
Traditional loyalty programs were built on transactions: points per purchase, discounts after repeat visits, early access to sales. These models still work, but they don’t generate lasting emotional bonds. If another company offers a better discount, the customer can switch instantly.
Today’s consumers, especially younger generations, expect brands to align with their social, environmental, and cultural values. A McKinsey study revealed that 70% of Gen Z consumers try to purchase from brands they consider ethical, and 63% are willing to pay more to do so. This behavior points to a deeper kind of loyalty—where customers stay because leaving feels like betraying their own values.
Think about Patagonia’s consistent stance on environmental responsibility. When they ran their famous “Don’t Buy This Jacket” campaign, discouraging unnecessary consumption, it didn’t hurt sales—it strengthened loyalty. Customers didn’t just like Patagonia gear; they believed in Patagonia as a company. That level of trust can’t be won with coupons or tiered points alone.
Many brands attempt to attach themselves to cultural movements or causes, but consumers are increasingly skilled at spotting performative gestures. A recycled logo during Pride Month or a generic sustainability claim without proof doesn’t foster loyalty; it creates skepticism.
Authenticity requires consistent actions across the business. Starbucks faced criticism when promoting racial equity initiatives while simultaneously receiving backlash for internal policies that contradicted the message. The misalignment diluted trust. On the other hand, Ben & Jerry’s has repeatedly taken bold stances on social justice issues, often at risk of alienating some customer groups, but that very risk-taking has strengthened their loyal base who values courage and consistency.
The key takeaway: customers don’t need brands to stand for every cause, but they need them to stand firmly for the causes they do embrace—and show evidence of living those commitments across the business, not just in marketing campaigns.
Consider how Apple frames privacy as a core value in its marketing. Competitors may offer more affordable devices with comparable features, but Apple customers often choose to pay a premium because they believe their personal data is safer. That belief drives loyalty beyond features and price.
In food and beverage, brands like Oatly gained momentum not only because of product innovation but because they tapped into cultural conversations around climate change and animal welfare. Customers weren’t just buying oat milk; they were buying into a statement about the kind of future they wanted to see.
These examples highlight a growing truth: loyalty programs that focus only on transactions risk being commoditized. But when customers connect their purchase with a sense of identity or contribution to a greater purpose, they don’t simply consume—they participate.
Shared values naturally foster community, and community deepens loyalty. Nike’s investment in initiatives like “Nike Run Club” and “Nike Training Club” apps isn’t just about selling sneakers—it’s about uniting people around a shared commitment to health, performance, and self-improvement.
Community-driven loyalty often includes peer validation. Customers feel part of something bigger when they see others engaging in the same behaviors, whether that’s sharing workouts, posting eco-friendly purchases, or supporting small local makers. This network effect transforms loyalty into a collective experience, not an isolated transaction.
Platforms like Rediem support this by allowing brands to design communities that go beyond discounts. They enable customers to participate in shared missions, earn recognition for value-driven behaviors, and interact with each other in meaningful ways. When loyalty is framed as belonging rather than buying, it becomes far harder to break.
If loyalty is tied to values, businesses need to measure more than purchase frequency. Engagement indicators—such as participation in community programs, shares of cause-related content, or referrals driven by belief in the brand’s mission—become critical signals.
Brands like TOMS shifted their one-for-one giving model after realizing that while the campaign was popular, customers wanted deeper engagement with the causes they supported. Instead of only tracking how many pairs of shoes were donated, TOMS began focusing on long-term impact and storytelling around community projects. The metric of success became customer alignment and advocacy, not just units sold.
This shift in measurement allows marketers to evaluate not just who is buying, but why they are buying—and whether that “why” ties back to brand values in a way that ensures loyalty over time.
Taking a stand on values isn’t risk-free. By aligning strongly with certain beliefs, brands may alienate parts of their potential audience. Gillette’s 2019 campaign addressing toxic masculinity sparked widespread debate—garnering praise from some and boycotts from others.
The reality is that strong values create polarity. But neutrality can be even riskier. In a marketplace saturated with choices, blandness fails to inspire loyalty. Brands that choose to stand for something must prepare for backlash, but they also gain the chance to build a passionate, committed base that won’t switch for discounts.
Value-based loyalty is not a marketing tactic—it’s a brand identity strategy. Customers are no longer satisfied with transactional perks alone; they want to align their spending power with their beliefs. Brands that respond with authenticity, consistency, and measurable action will find themselves rewarded with something far stronger than repeat purchases: unwavering loyalty.
In the end, when customers choose you for what you stand for, they’re not just buying your product—they’re endorsing your place in their world.
ready to make the switch? we automatically migrate your customers points from Yotpo, Smile and others so your customers don't miss a beat.
.png){kind=icon}
